Current:Home > MarketsSecession: Why some in Oregon want to become part of Idaho-InfoLens
Secession: Why some in Oregon want to become part of Idaho
View Date:2024-12-23 16:35:38
Mike McCarter knows his American history almost as well as he knows his Bible. His family has lived and worshipped in Oregon for four generations. "The only time I lived out of the state was during the Vietnam War when I was in the military," he said.
But his Oregon may not be the Oregon you're thinking of, the one with the misty rugged coastline, pinot noir wineries, and its loyally Blue politics.
McCarter lives in the town of La Pine, in the state's rural and more sparsely populated part – the Red side of Oregon.
"It's almost like the Grand Canyon goes right along the Cascade Range," he told correspondent Lee Cowan. "It is a big divide."
What that means politically, he says, is that the Blue part of Western Oregon always outweighs the Eastern part's Red. "In talking to a legislator over in the Portland area, I said, 'The legislature doesn't listen to our people, our representatives over here.' He said, 'Whoa whoa whoa, stop, Mike. We hear what they're staying. We just out-vote you.'"
So, McCarter decided to look for greener pastures - or in this case, at least ones a little more red. Last fall, when "Sunday Morning" first met McCarter, he was spearheading a campaign called Move Oregon's Border. The group had been busy introducing ballot measures all across the state asking voters about the idea of pushing the urban, Blue bits of Oregon into a smaller but still populous state, and then taking the rural Red bits and creating what would be part of a more expansive Idaho.
Sandie Gilson owns a real estate business in rural John Day, Oregon, which is closer to Boise than it is Portland in virtually every way. She told Cowan, "When you have a government that won't listen to the opposition, or take into account those of us that live out here, then we have no government representation."
Cowan asked Gilson, "Are you optimistic that you think you have a chance?"
"I look at it like the American Revolution was a big hurdle to make, and they did it," she replied.
It'd been a year since "Sunday Morning" visited, so Cowan went back, to find out how things stood.
Back then, nine counties had voted in favor of considering making Eastern Oregon part of Idaho. Now, that number is up 12, with another set to vote next May.
"We're getting into people's heads about this," McCarter said.
As for Idaho, well, it's at least open to discussions. This past spring Idaho's state representatives approved a measure to begin a dialogue with Oregon over whether and how to redraw their common boundary.
But so far, McCarter said Oregon is playing hard to get, at least in public. "We've heard from behind the scenes, 'Wait a minute, if we fund a bridge in Eastern Oregon, why would be we do that if it's going to become Idaho?'" he said.
But the opposition has swung into gear, too. A Portland non-profit called Western States Center is branding the move a "radical change" that would raise taxes and cut wages. Comparing it to Oregon's past white nationalists hate groups, one ad declares, "Members of Patriot Group, a white nationalist hate group, support a secession. Makes you wonder: Why are violent extremists pushing for secession?"
Their message: If rural conservatives don't like Oregon's urban liberal leanings, well, don't move the border, move themselves instead.
McCarter said, "We're not running away from the problem, we're not going to run away and move to Idaho. We're going to deal with the problem right here and now."
There are a lot of details still to be ironed out, and the devil is in every one of them. Not to mention the fact that actually changing the border would require both Oregon and Idaho to agree, and would then need approval by the U.S. Congress.
Richard Kreitner, author of the book "Break It Up: Secession, Division, and the Secret History of America's Imperfect Union," says it's hardly a new idea: "I don't think that we should act like state lines are written in stone. We should look at them and say, 'Does this actually make sense?'
"Secession has always been there. Catholics lived in Maryland, debtors lived in Georgia, you know, Puritans lived in New England. They were kind of separate to begin with. And that's why they wanted nothing to do with one another."
"So, it's really woven into our DNA?" asked Cowan.
"Absolutely. There's nothing sacred about Oregon. There's nothing sacred about Delaware or my native New Jersey, in my opinion. You know, these are just kind of inherited forms."
Mike McCarter will be the first to tell you that moving Oregon's border is radical. But, he says, if we've learned anything about our politics in the last several years, it's that "conventional" seems so yesterday.
"I mean, as fast as things are changing in this country right now, why can't we?" he said. "Why can't people still have the right to vote for who governs them?"
For more info:
- GreaterIdaho.org
- "Break It Up: Secession, Division, and the Secret History of America's Imperfect Union" by Richard Kreitner (Little, Brown and Co.), in Hardcover, eBook and Audio formats, available via Amazon, Barnes & Noble and Bookshop.org
- richardkreitner.com
- Western States Center
Story produced by Michelle Kessel. Editor: Remington Korper.
- In:
- Idaho
- Oregon
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Jordan Chiles Reveals She Still Has Bronze Medal in Emotional Update After 2024 Olympics Controversy
- Krispy Kreme unveils new Paris-inspired doughnut collection ahead of 2024 Olympics
- The Best Amazon Prime Day 2024 Alternative Sales: 60% Off Wayfair, 50% Off Old Navy, 20% Off MAC & More
- Hybrid work still has some kinks to work out | The Excerpt
- Anti-abortion advocates press Trump for more restrictions as abortion pill sales spike
- Hamas says Gaza cease-fire talks haven't paused and claims military chief survived Israeli strike
- Gareth Southgate resigns as England manager after Euro 2024 final loss
- Messi 'doing well' after Copa America ankle injury, says he'll return 'hopefully soon'
- 'Dangerous and unsanitary' conditions at Georgia jail violate Constitution, feds say
- New Jersey Democrats set to pick candidate in special House primary for Donald Payne Jr.'s seat
Ranking
- New Orleans marks with parade the 64th anniversary of 4 little girls integrating city schools
- U.K.'s King Charles III to visit Australia and Samoa on first royal tour abroad since cancer diagnosis
- Trump expected to announce his VP running mate today as RNC gets underway
- 'NCIS: Tony & Ziva' reveals daughter Tali as production begins in Hungary
- Democrat Cleo Fields wins re-drawn Louisiana congressional district, flipping red seat blue
- After Donald Trump shot at rally, Russia, China and other foreign powers weigh in on assassination attempt
- Kaspersky to shutter US operations after its software is banned by Commerce Department, citing risk
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Crack Open
Recommendation
-
25 monkeys caught but more still missing after escape from research facility in SC
-
Chrishell Stause & Paige DeSorbo Use These Teeth Whitening Strips: Save 35% During Amazon Prime Day
-
Victim of Texas inmate set for execution was loving schoolteacher, pillar of her community
-
Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Crack Open
-
Joel Embiid injury, suspension update: When is 76ers star's NBA season debut?
-
Carlos Alcaraz beats Novak Djokovic at Wimbledon men's final to win fourth Grand Slam title
-
Carbon monoxide leak at Fulton County jail sends 1 worker to the hospital; requires treatment for 5
-
Why pasta salad isn't always healthy, even with all those vegetables